How much discount if payng all cash?
Started by pdf123
over 17 years ago
Posts: 7
Member since: Mar 2009
Discussion about
I am looking at buying an apartment with no mortgage and I am curious to how much discount (if any) should I expect compared to some one who is contingent on mortgage approval. Also, if the seller broker asks whether i am taking on a mortage, is there any downside to telling the truth? Thanks!
I am looking at buying an apartment with no mortgage and I am curious to how much discount (if any) should I expect compared to some one who is contingent on mortgage approval.
Also, if the seller broker asks whether i am taking on a mortage, is there any downside to telling the truth?
Thanks!
No downside at all to telling the broker unless you think you may change your mind and want a mortgage. The seller would be very happy to sign a contract with no mortgage contingency and is more likely to be flexible on price. Definitely gives you an edge if there are other offers out there.
all cash vs an offer with no mortgage contingency can be the same to a seller- such as, if a person is buying for 2 million n is only taking a 500k mortgage and is more than qualifed to get it, they will make that offer with no contingencies most likely..
all cash situations are best in buildings where financing is not permitted- new developments, smaller developments, etc.. and they need cash buyers and u will get a good deal there
pdf123,
In my opinion, your first lowball should not be cash, use the cash offer as a counter.
very good point bugelrex! at this point the average discount to listing price is around 12%, so just get that w/o using your cash advantage. you could leave that for later in order to get a further discount.
I don't think you get any discount. Seller makes the same money either way. What you get is your bid accepted if the rest of your financials check out. Maybe you can shave a couple percent from what you would bid otherwise. Not more. From a seller's perspective, they still need to know you'll pass the board and a no-mortgage deal doesn't guarantee that at all. Boards are going to scrutinize your income stream and reserves just as much regardless of whether you are taking a mortgage. For instance, buying without a mortgage, a board will want to know your credit history, how you are going to make the maintenance payments, where the money came from for the purchase, and your overall financial picture, and what kind of neighbor you'll make. A trust fund baby doesn't go over well with many boards. Nor does someone with problematic reasons for paying 100% up front--it actually can be a yellow flag.
kylewest, I think your response MAY apply to a co-op, but with regards to the purchase of a condo, an all cash, no contingent offer carries a tremendous amount of weight in this environment and commands serious negotiation power. The amount of leverage it affords depends usually on how long the apartment has been on the market, how many failed deals the seller has already seen go down the drain, and the motivation level of the seller. Also, so many apartments in the Manhattan are priced SO far out of line with where they should be, that the degree of the mis-pricing would be essential to estimate the 'discount' that should be applied.
re: your last point. mis priced is mis priced i.e. a well qualified yet not all cash buyer doesn't want to (nor need to) overpay either.
not sure there is an exact number but does factor into things... i had two offers one was cash and a little lower (2.5%). I went with the cash deal.
Admin - where are you getting that 12% figure? I assume that is from the last listed price, not the starting price?
jlnyc50, can you provide examples of Manhattan listings with no financing allowed, i.e. all cash required? Thanks.
financing is allowed in buildings if you can get it
650 sixth avenue is 30% sold out only, impossible to get financing, any building with more than 20% retail space is less attractive under new guidelines (1 Irving Place, 15 e 26th)- you can get financing, but higher rates..
any new development not 70% sold out banks are not lending to
email me for more- djm456@aol.com
also the laurel -401 e 67th street on the upper east
poor 650 Sixth. Everything about it is just so wrong.
We found that a cash deal really had little effect on the price - take into consideratin that we bought in a VERY different market. We tried to use it while negotiating price. Since there were multiple bidders it helped distinguish us from others where the deal might fall apart because of failed financing. Further, it makes you more appealing to the Board - they LOVE all cash deals - it minimizes risk. But in the end, there was no price concession because we paid all cash. The seller didn"t care whether he got his $ from us or from a bank.
dmag2020, you are right: I was addressing my comments to co-ops.
I exchanged emails with a broker with a listing @800k. I said I might be interested at 650k. I was told that the owner said he would entertain my highest all cash offer. I haven't seen a mortgage written on the building since October (where the commitment was probably August or September 2008), which I think is interesting since the sponsor owns 45% of the building. One deal in the building has be "under contract" for the past 3.5 months. The broker says that that deal is all cash.
Many financed deals in the recent past were 10% equity, and clearly no one is getting those deals today. I think all cash deserves a discount.
jlynyc50, bny mellon was lending on the Laurel a couple of months ago, did they stop?
In general, it's a tough market and I would think all cash would get you an ease-of-deal discount, but it's not going to be more than 5%. Bear in mind that volume is so slow that if you are up against another bidder, they're likely to be cash buyers as well.
ali r.
{downtown broker}