Renting in NYC: The Ultimate Guide
Key takeaways:
- A rental broker can help you find listings, arrange tours, submit applications, and act as a go-between for renters and landlords.
- Many brokers on rental listings represent the landlord, not the renter. However, a renter can choose to hire their own broker who works only for them.
- Hiring your own broker can be especially helpful for busy, out-of-town, or first-time NYC renters who are seeking market expertise and a more streamlined search.
- A renter who hires their own broker pays a negotiated broker fee, typically one month’s rent or 10–15% of the annual rent. Under the FARE Act, landlords pay the broker fee for brokers they hire.
- Choose a broker with relevant experience and strong communication, and avoid anyone who pressures you to pay or sign anything before you’re comfortable.
It’s widely known that buying or selling a home in New York City is challenging and complicated, but surprise surprise — renting one can be too. With elevated rents, high upfront costs, and fierce competition, renting here is unlike renting in any other city. Considerably, some New Yorkers decide to work with a rental agent, or broker, to help them navigate this matrix of madness. But does hiring a broker make sense for you? StreetEasy® has the answers to all your burning broker questions.
Manhattan Rentals Under $3,500 on StreetEasy Article continues below
What does a broker do in NYC?
In this context, a broker is a licensed real estate professional who handles the logistics of renting out apartments. They may also be called rental brokers or rental agents, but simply “broker” is common. Brokers do things like finding listings, showing apartments, and helping renters with applications. Simply put, they act as a middleperson between renters and landlords. In New York State, brokers must pass an exam and meet certain educational requirements to earn their license.
Who does a broker work for?
Here’s where things can get a little confusing. On a given rental listing, you might be instructed to contact the broker, or contact the landlord (or property management company) who then connects you with the broker. Most of the time, this broker has been hired by the landlord, and their goal is to find ideal tenants for this particular rental unit or building. The broker provides services to the landlord like marketing the apartment, showing units, answering applicants’ questions, and helping with the application and tenant selection process. So, the broker works for the landlord — they don’t work solely for you.
Alternatively, as a renter, you can hire your own broker who works only for you. The rest of this article addresses hiring your own broker, including what they can do for renters, how to find one, and the costs involved.

Reasons to hire your own broker
When you hire your own broker, their job is to find you a suitable apartment to rent, regardless of what building it’s in. They can be beneficial if you want to cast a wide net through someone who intimately knows the NYC rental market. A broker can also be helpful if you’re an out-of-town apartment hunter and can’t do in-person tours, if you have a busy schedule that makes searching and touring difficult, or if you’re new to the NYC market.
“[Brokers] often have the inside track on landlords, their practices, and how their leases work,” says Ellen Sykes, a licensed associate real estate broker with Christies International Real Estate New York.
Your broker will contact landlords to arrange showings for you, as well as help you apply for the apartments you’re interested in. They may also be more aggressive than you might be about negotiating rent and lease terms, or asking for rent concessions. By acting as a middleperson and advocate for you, they can save you time, stress, and possibly money as they help you find a rental you truly love.
“A good rental broker will understand what you’re looking for and know which buildings might be a good match for you. They’ll be able to weed out listings that don’t suit your needs,” says Becki Danchik, licensed associate real estate broker with Christies International Real Estate New York. “Nobody wants to have renter’s remorse. You should feel great about the place you’re calling home, and working with a broker can help make that a reality.”
Brooklyn Rentals Under $3,500 on StreetEasy Article continues below
Do I need to pay broker fees?
If you hire your own broker who successfully finds you an apartment to rent, you’ll need to pay them a broker fee, which is an agreed-upon commission on the deal. That commission (fee) is negotiable, but it usually ranges from one month’s rent to 10-15% of the annual rent. It’s paid by you, the renter. Make sure the fee, and any other terms, are clearly spelled out in a written agreement before you decide to work with a particular broker.
What about the other scenario, where you rent an apartment through a broker hired by the landlord? The FARE Act, in effect since June 2025, made paying broker fees the responsibility of the hiring party. So, if you work with a broker hired by the landlord, the landlord pays the broker fee. For more information, see our explainer on what the FARE Act means for renters or visit our NYC Renters’ Rights resource hub.
Queens Rentals Under $3,000 on StreetEasy Article continues below
How to find a broker
Word-of-mouth is a common way for New Yorkers to connect with brokers. Ask your friends, family, and extended network if they’ve worked with a broker they’d recommend, and have them put you in touch. You can also find one through a brokerage that specializes in rentals, or one that handles both sales and rentals (which many do).
If you have a broker in mind, search their name on StreetEasy and see if they have an agent profile, where you can learn about the broker and get a sense of their experience. Under the Active listings tab, you’ll see their current listings — a good indicator of their activity in the market. Go to the Past deals tab to see listings they’ve successfully rented to others in the past. If they seem like they could be a good fit for your search, you can send them a message directly from their profile.
Best practices for hiring a broker
A great broker can save you time, effort, and money. Here are some tips on hiring the best one for you, including what to look for and what to avoid.
- Look for a broker with relevant experience. Ask the broker about their previous rental deals, or check their agent profile on StreetEasy. It can be beneficial to hire someone with experience in the neighborhood, building, type of apartment, or price point you’re seeking.
- Pay attention to their responsiveness, ability to answer questions, and overall service. These qualities are essential in NYC’s complex, fast-paced rental market.
- Be wary of brokers who make you feel rushed or pressured. While brokers certainly want to close a deal, you shouldn’t be expected to make a payment right away or sign something immediately. A great broker will take the time to vet listings and walk you through the application process, so you feel comfortable.